Do you have the need to run MS-Windows applications on Linux?

Yes
72% (6054 votes)
No
28% (2393 votes)
Total votes: 8447
Carlie Fairchild - Wed, 2004-12-08 19:30.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

CAD programmes

Try BricsCAD, They are beta testing the basic version of thier CAD programme to run in WINE. You can apply to be a tester and they will give you a serial no. The programme is easy to download and comes with its own unpackager and installer - very easy. The programme is basic, and does not have the architecturals pluggins last time I looked.

I was trying to get on with this untill i upraded my pc. to amd64 with pcie graphics and serial ata raid. I can not now run my SuSe 9.2 as it will not now get further than the kernel load, then goes blank. Back to windows im afraid. Its all very well for all these smug windows hating IT geeks slagging off people who dont know how to get this wonderfull OS working, perhaps they also know how to design and project manage a £M construction project as well as understanding how to get linux to recognize and use new hardware???? Derrrrrrr ...i dont think so. For us professionals out in the real world were PC's are merely tools used to doing real work, I regret to say that you cant do without windows.

Sean (not verified) - Sat, 2005-04-16 04:22.

Tax and accounting on Linux

Right now, there are few accounting packages for small businesses on Linux, and no (nil, zero, zilch) tax packages.

The Linux accounting packages I've seen are not as good as Simply Accounting or .

The alternative for taxes are on-line freebies which work fine under any old browser, but nothing that retains your previous year's data AFAIK.

lordshipmayhem (not verified) - Sat, 2005-03-12 13:49.

Doing My 2004 Taxes in Linux. Or Trying.

I tried really, really hard to do my taxes under Linux this year. I'm in the USA and just installed SUSE 9 on our home computer as the primary system (Wintendo 2k is installed as a dual boot for a little longer during this transition).

I tried the online tax software at turbotax.com and taxcut.com. I tested with both IE under Crossover Office and with Firefox. turbotax.com simply wouldn't launch completely at all! Seems to me they've done some unnecessarily funky stuff wtih their web app; I simply coudn't get past login. taxcut.com did much better; I was able to complete my taxes using that system. The core functionality worked fine, but the popup helps did not work under Firefox, only under IE/cxoffice.

However, taxcut.com was going to cost me upwards of $60-70 to file (federal + state). From OfficeMax, after rebates (which were not available for the on-line product), filing cost me $25. So, I launched W2K and did my taxes there. If I'm going to spend the extra to use LInux, I'd rather that extra $25 go to an open source company, so I'll send it to my favorite project.

And, you TaxCut guys, get your marketing folks in line! The online app ought to be cheaper (or at least the same price) as the in-store application!

Max (not verified) - Sat, 2005-04-09 14:18.

MS-Windows applications on Linux

I am now a full time user of Linux Xandros. I do not feel like I missed any MS-Windows application, except Anti-virus, Anti-spy, Anti-hack, Anti-crack, Anti-????.......But god blessing, I don't need any of them now. I don't have to waste most of my time on this garbage in order to make the damn machine functioning.
All thanks to Linux Community and also to TUX where I learned the concepts of Linux.

Mubarak Al-Jaber (not verified) - Thu, 2005-03-10 07:13.

I am sick of M$ (esp now with

I am sick of M$ (esp now with their effing authentication crap {i work at a small computer store and do wipe/reinstalls at least 3 times a week}) and am doing a full port of my home network. However I...um..backup alot of my movies (kids and all), and I use DVD Decrypter and Shrink to do most of that. Sometimes AnyDVD will take the place of Decrypter. I am looking for a program that will provide the same function as Decrypter and Shrink, and while we're at it, Alchohol. Unless WINE will give me that functionality. Anyone?

Stitch (not verified) - Tue, 2005-03-08 18:39.

M$ authentication = Last Straw

Amen to that brother. I'm your typical home user with just enough HW & SW savvy to throw together a new PC or upgrade my existing one - not w/o frequent hiccups mind you. Recently ran into a problem during an upgrade to my 3 yr old Presario that locked me out of the MoBo BIOS. Since it was a bit old anyway I ended up having to replace my MoBo so decide to also replace the CPU, video card, RAM, & PS with the main goal of retaining my original HD as is so I wouldn't lose my apps and data...

Come to find out that enough 'critical' components were changed to require WinXP activation... BUT, since I had an OEM vsn that came w/ the Compaq my changes were 'too' significant to justify it being the same system so I'd have to buy a new copy of Windows since I'm installing in on a 'new' PC...

What crap. All I want to do is get my PC back up and running w/o messing w/ or erasing my hard drive. I didn't want to put in that many new components but it's what I had to do to get back up and running.

Well, that did it for me... it's why I'm at this site now in fact. It has prompted me to do research into favorable newbie distros (only have a few days worth of Suse experience from a bit of playing around I did a couple of years ago).

Gonna put my old HD in the system AND a new one. My original to keep my home and business stuff going while I put Linux on the other and gradually ween myself off of windows completely.

If XP pulls this sh** I shudder to think of what type of wallet crushing, privacy erasing, enslavement tools Longhorn will have...

Let the Linux freedom adventure begin,
Malac

Malac (not verified) - Fri, 2005-04-08 13:05.

I've used the same XP license

I've used the same XP license for 3 motherboards, various RAM upgrades, hard drive upgrades and so on.

My Windows applications, mainly games, run much better in Windows so I use Windows to play games. They run slower than molasses in any distro.

An - ymous (not verified) - Wed, 2005-04-13 21:23.

Check out 'dvdrip' for DVD ->

Check out 'dvdrip' for DVD -> CD conversion or 'lxdvdrip' for a good DVD -> DVD backup.

lxdvdrip is basically a frontend to a bunch of other DVD programs (ie: DVDbackup, DVDauthor, transcode, etc.). It will print out what program it is about to use and what arguements it'll send.

Using the other DVD apps, lxdvdrip will shrink dual-layer DVD's to fit on a standard single layer DVD+/-R(W). For single-layer DVD's, it'll create a straight backup of it.

HTH...

An - ymous (not verified) - M - , 2005-04-04 16:23.

What functionality do you nee

What functionality do you need from Alcohol?

Komakino (not verified) - Fri, 2005-04-01 15:34.

Well, as far as functionality

Well, as far as functionality from Alchohol...The ability to mount images, such as .iso, mdf/s, cue/bin's. Other times to make images. Such as this DVD i built with Adobe Encore. NOthing else would copy it, so i made an image with Alochol, saved to my hdd, then burned the image with alcohol to make several copies. All legimate uses, to be sure. I love the program, but am willing to make the switch if there is a viable alternative. I saw that WINE can use DVD Shrink and Decrypter. I'll try the other suggestions in the above reply also. Now also, is there an application like Encore that will build DVD's. Don't like pinnical. Possibly Premiere or Premiere elements. I like the Adobe suite because of the integration. Does Linux have an equivilant suite? Oh, yeah...Windows --- Pike off!

Stitch (not verified) - Thu, 2005-04-14 14:51.

Mounting ISO Images

Linux has native support for mounting ISO images as if they were a local drive. I currently keep a copy of my Linux distro on the hard disk as an ISO permanently mounted as a virtual DVD to install new software from when needed, as well as install from the net (for new packages) directly from the distro's FTP or HTTP sites. It's really rather nice to NEVER be asked for the disk when installing new software even if it does eat up a sizable chunk of HD space. 8)

An - ymous (not verified) - Sun, 2005-04-17 06:03.

Authentication sickness!!

When I heard about that authentication crap, that
was the very day I went looking for Linux distro
that a beginner to Linux could easily install and
use right away. I found it. No more M$ CRAP!!!!

skbarr (not verified) - Fri, 2005-03-11 12:57.

I have been trying to convert

I have been trying to convert to linux for three years, I cannot get it to support even half my games. I do like it, but need more win apps.

Treefrog (not verified) - Sun, 2005-03-06 07:13.

Kids' Games

We're 95% Linux (suse) at home now. I have W2K as a dual boot for some of the kids game CDs that I simply cannot run under Wine or Crossover Office. The kids haven't forced the issue and so far, none of their games are actually installed in Windows; they've been content w/ the online games they can use.

Most online games work for them, but a few require Windows-only plugins. I'll have to get a personal of Crossover for that. (My Crossover is now under a corproate license, but it's custom, so the plugin is missing since it's not a corporate need.) To save on cost, I'll probably by a single Personal copy of Crossover and set up a single user account on the PC to install it to. The $40 license only installs once (we have 5 logins in the family), and I'm not excited about a $75 license to share a single install (5 kids, $40 is a enough). They only need cxoffice for a few things, so I think I can sell them on going to a "gaming" login for that functionality.

Still doesn't solve the game CDs, including the educational CDs that simply won't run. But I'm hoping Codeweaver's can make good on it's goal to have 95% of all windows software running properly on cxoffice by year-end. They do that, I'll find the $75.....

Max (not verified) - Sat, 2005-04-09 14:24.

PLCs, servo/stepper ...

I work with PLCs and stepper, servo, linear motor controllers and
they all have setup / programming software that ONLY runs on Windows.

C - trol Freak (not verified) - Thu, 2005-03-03 08:54.

I only run Adobe Photoshop, S

I only run Adobe Photoshop, Sphere, and of course, Windows-only games.

Everything else is obviously Linux-only.

Quest-Master (not verified) - Tue, 2005-02-22 17:40.

Why Photoshop?

What is it Photoshop supplies that you can't do with the GIMP?

An - ymous (not verified) - M - , 2005-03-21 04:24.

Photoshop supports CMYK whe

Photoshop supports CMYK where GIMP does not from what I understand. CMYK is import when printing

An - ymous (not verified) - Thu, 2005-04-07 10:32.

http://www.blackfiveservices.

http://www.blackfiveservices.co.uk/separate.shtml
GIMP plugin for CMYK
Doesn't anyone use Google anymore?

An - ymous (not verified) - Sat, 2005-04-09 21:30.

No!!!

I'd rather support new, open source, native Linux applications, such as Lsongs, Nvu, Lphoto. Thanks Linspire for sponsoring these projects and helping ween us all away from expensive, proprietary MS software!

Hans

Hans (not verified) - Sun, 2005-02-20 14:46.

Me too.. but I have just gott

Me too.. but I have just gotten my soundcard working, and loaded nvidia drivers to get my resolution right in SUSE. And next I suppose I'll learn the command console and an editor and then learn to install software and then I'll be weaned from XP and just in time too.. renewal fees are due soon on my anti-virus and other support software to hold XP together ;)

Bob (not verified) - Wed, 2005-02-23 02:06.

Apps I run on XP windows

I am new and just installed SuSE 9.2 which supports my hardware, but my soundcard only partially. I am using Adobe Illustrator, and Photoshop in Windows XP. I also have an entire drive dedicated to Visual Studio .NET and have just learned to write my own applications for XP windows. I would like to do the same for Linux, but I'm just starting out here. Also I am interested in 3D application software maybe blender, and multimedia in general.

Bob (not verified) - Thu, 2005-02-17 20:11.

Running Windows on Xandros

I am in the process of completing my college education and have been using Xandros for about two years now. I have just upgraded to Xandros 3.0 and find it to be a leap forward from version 2.0. The college requires its students to have the ability to run many cdroms from textbooks and online sites on windows and WebCt only supports Internet Explorer.

Since Win4Lin now has a $29.95 version of its excellent software, I have installed it on top of Xandros and then installed Windows ME in Win4Lin. This combination is killer! I have the ability to work in Xandros for 90% of all I do and the other 10% is handled by ME on Win4Lin, a win win situation I guess you could say.

penguin7009

penguin7009 (not verified) - Tue, 2005-02-15 17:52.

Office

I recently changed my windows xp for fedora core 2. I found it really amazing, I got wine
to run my windows programs in linux and that solved 98 percent of my problems.
the only programs im not able to run are huge games made for M$ but i dont care
I'm a 15 yr old student, thats why I play video games

jamvor (not verified) - Sun, 2005-02-13 16:08.

Need to run FINALE, available

Need to run FINALE, available for Apple & Windows.

An - ymous (not verified) - Fri, 2005-02-11 10:12.

Photo Organizer

The only application that keeps me from recycling the windows partition is BrilliantPhoto. It lets me tag pictures with names, keywords, places, and that info is stored in the image as an IPTC tag. I looked at Mapivi, Imgseek, and a few other alpha works, but nothing would retrieve the IPTC info already in the thousands of pictures that I have. If I could only get it to run in wine (it won't)...

Dotan

Dotan Cohen (not verified) - M - , 2005-02-07 17:08.

Mapivi and BrilliantPhoto

Hi,

I just tagged some pics with BrilliantPhoto and I'm able to see the added info with Mapivi without problems.
The keywords are visible in the IPTC keywords of the pictures.
The people are in the contact IPTC tag (which is wrong IMHO), the rating is in the urgency, but they use it the wrong way: urgency 1 is the higest, not 5.
Also they store the place in the wrong tags, but anyway the information is there and visible and searchable using Mapivi.

Regards
Martin

Martin Herrmann (not verified) - Tue, 2005-03-22 09:12.

Brilliant Photo or...

Keep speaking up about your needs, and a programmer
will pick up on it and write a program for it.

skbarr (not verified) - Fri, 2005-03-11 12:42.

Dotan, have you considered Wi

Dotan, have you considered Win4Lin? Win4Lin has a new Home edition for $29.95 us, which will run Windows 95, 98, 98SE and ME on top of Linux. Its just like having another application open in your Linux desktop. You just click on the icon and Windows opens giving you direct access to Windows on top of Linux. If you want to know more about it, just type in Win4Lin in you browser and it will goto Win4Lin.

penguin7009

An - ymous (not verified) - Tue, 2005-02-15 17:56.

That doesn't sound much bette

That doesn't sound much better than what I'm doing now- I have a KVM and switch to the windows box for picture managment. Also, I have started using Media Player 10 on the windows box, which is nice because it is a great program, and it frees up the linux box (Ferdora Core 3) a little.

But I would be willing to pay full price for BrilliantPhoto or something similar, so long as it works with the IPTC data that I already have in the photos. I moved to linux not because I am cheap (I already HAVE a windows license), but because I do not feel that Microsoft makes a quality operating system. They do make other good software (Media Player 10, Access), and nothing beats the Microsoft wireless keyboards, but I do not trust XP, IE, or Outlook.

Dotan (not verified) - M - , 2005-03-14 03:42.

Windows Apps On Linux

I have been running MS Excel/Word/Access & Powerpoint on Xandros Linux for a
year now with no problems. Just stick the cd in and install. The only thing I can't
get to work is the game Civilation II, which is the only game I loved in Windows.
However Civ II and I will bet Civ III will run fine in Win4Lin. Windows ? Who needs it.

dw5437 (not verified) - Sat, 2005-02-05 19:49.

FreeCiv

You should try FreeCiv

An - ymous (not verified) - Wed, 2005-02-09 11:17.

there is a version of Civ on

there is a version of Civ on linux natively and its free. Can't remember how to get it but check on google should tell you.

An - ymous (not verified) - M - , 2005-02-07 16:18.

MS-Windows applications on Linux?

Yes, at a minimum I need to be able to run the income-tax-return preparation program that I've used for years, TaxCut, at least till a good Open Source tax program appears. Such a program seems to me unlikely since the major investment is not so much the programming as the tax and accounting expertise required.

I also use a personal-finance program, InCharge!, which now holds over 10 years' worth of my data. That's too much of a legacy for me to abandon it easily, even though I've heard good things about GnuCash.

R - Wyllys (not verified) - Thu, 2005-02-03 20:54.

income tax prep software

go to www.irs.gov and you have a choice of over 10 (as I recall) options for free fed tax preparation. I've used H & R Block for several years with no probs. It's all browser based so you don't have to download or install any software. Thus it should run fine under linux.

Joe (not verified) - Sun, 2005-02-13 22:47.

Turbotax runs fine with Codeweaver's

Obviously unsupported, but I had no problem using TurboTax 2005 under Codeweaver's Crossover Office. I live in Texas, so I did not test any state tax stuff.

Chris Cox (not verified) - M - , 2005-02-07 10:47.

There are several income tax

There are several income tax programs that you can run online. Tax Act is one, TurboTax has an online version, I don't know about Tax Cut. I don't know if these programs need Internet Explorer to run, but I'd be surprised if they wouldn't run on Mozilla or FireFox.

An - ymous (not verified) - Thu, 2005-02-03 22:41.

InfoSelect Personal Information Manager

There appears to be no decent Personal Information Manager available for Linux.
Info Select for Windows ( http://www.miclog.com/ ) is the award-winning Personal Information Manager that organizes Internet data, notes, to-do's, schedules, contacts, addresses, forms, ideas, images, and much more.
This application has for me made my life much more easily organised than would be possible otherwise. In fact, though I detest using Windoze, I am addicted to InfoSelect.
InfoSelect combines the best features of a word processor, a free-form database and a personal information manager to capture and organize many different kinds of text-based information. InfoSelect 7.0 is ideal for users who deal with lots of information. It helps to you do three things really well: grab information, organize it, and search it.
InfoSelect's simple layout invites the user to create topics and begin to compile notes. The information they contain can come in almost any digital form - documents, spreadsheets, databases, grids, forms, graphics, photos, Web pages, emails, posts from newsgroups, scanned images, calendars with alarms.
I had it working under Wine and RedHat 7.2 but subsequent changes in Wine have prevented me using it under Linux as I do not have the necessary skill to overcome the problems encountered in the installation phase under later versions of Linux.
This application is crying out for an OSS clone.

Brian J - es (not verified) - Sun, 2005-01-30 17:05.

You might want to consider us

You might want to consider using Evolution. Though it may not be quite as robust it has come along way last year.

Dave G (not verified) - Sat, 2005-02-12 14:20.

Look at Kontact if you use KD

Look at Kontact if you use KDE ... http://kontact.kde.org/

An - ymous (not verified) - Tue, 2005-02-08 00:17.

MS Programs I DON'T need

I haven't missed having to update my anti-virus program every morning 0r run my Ad Aware adbot search program. I don't miss having to give my name rank serial number and bank account every time I do something on my Fluxbox

An - ymous (not verified) - Sat, 2005-01-29 20:01.

I have two basic needs: 1)

I have two basic needs:

1) Some of my class websites for my university require Internet Explorer, and there are highly important materials only accessible from these sites. I doubt they'll change anything because the campus computer labs and libraries all have Windows boxes, so any complainers will just be directed to use the labs.

2) I use Finale, the music notation software. There is nothing (not Rosegarden, not NoteEdit, nothing) that comes close for Linux. Finale and Sibelius and the other full-featured music notation software for Windows and Mac just have no credible replacements.

An - ymous (not verified) - Fri, 2005-01-28 20:08.

Music stuff

I'm a straight Windows user (OK, reading this forum who's going to cast the first stone!) Actually, next time I get some money it's a new hard drive and Linux since it has suddenly occured to me that most of the software I use was built for that platform(!!) - Scribus, Gimp, Inkscape, Audacity et al.

Anyhow, as a professional musician/arranger/composer I used to use Sibelius (still do if it's straightforward stuff; one tune, no polyphony etc.) Now I use Lilypond via Cygwin with the JEdit Lilytools plug-in, and the extra time used inputting the straight data for the music files pays off immensely in the quality of the output (for an orchestral score in Sibelius I would reckon 60% of my time was spent refining the output - in Lilypond, perhaps 10% - the input time is roughly comparable, perhaps 5% more in Lilypond). Of course, it's a steep learning curve; but one that has, in my experience, paid off well.

Re the discussion going on here, well, I'll have to stick with Windows for some stuff, largely just for ease of communication with others. For the rest... well, if I don't go Linux within the next six weeks I promise to use MSOutlook for six months.. and that's punishment for you!

pianopete (not verified) - Tue, 2005-07-05 20:35.

I run GNU/Linux at work, and,

I run GNU/Linux at work, and, thanks to Ximian Evolution's Connector for MS Exchange Server, I didn't need to touch a Windows application for about a year. Sadly, that has now changed. We have recently changed help-desk applications. The one that we used before had a Web interface that worked just fine with Mozilla and Firefox, and it was quite serviceable. The new one, called Magic, works only with MS Internet Exploder. Apparently, they make CraptiveX system calls, and their HTML source even says "we really are dependent on IE".

Thus, I now have to run Internet Exploder, with CraptiveX, JavaScript, and cookies all turned on. For this purpose, I have a Windows XP into which I log in via rdesktop.

Sadly, I've learned that CiscoWorks 2000 also works only with MS Internet Exploder. Same with one other new application that we use.

An - ymous (not verified) - Thu, 2005-01-27 21:06.

RoboForm

AI RoboForm was one MS-Windows utility that I used every day. And when I wrote to the developer, requesting a Debian Linux version (I use ProMepis), he replied that there's not enough of a user-market to warrant the effort (to develop a paid version). The only thing similar that I've found is FireFox's extension, AutoForm, but it hasn't been workable for me.

An - ymous (not verified) - Thu, 2005-01-20 09:58.

RoboForm

Roboform is a good program...and it runs under Linux too..whit CrossOver...of course you have to install IE too... or you can use Firefox...

Dude (not verified) - Sun, 2005-07-03 17:56.

Win software needs

Access is about the only thing I can't leave behind; I don't think our corporation will ever abandon MS. I downloaded the pre-release version of OpenOffice, and tried Base, but found it has a

    very

long ways to go. Still, kudos to those who are contributing to its development.

Dana Payne (not verified) - Wed, 2005-01-19 13:36.

Open Office...

I have used open office and like it. I would like to know what you think is needed when you say it has a long ways to go.

John R. (not verified) - Wed, 2005-01-19 16:00.

Open Office

Wait for version 2.0 which is about to be released...then you can say goodbye to MS Office. Version 2 will include a database app.

DaveG (not verified) - Sat, 2005-02-12 14:14.

Open Office...

Hmmm.....to those who are used to the interface and feel of MS Office, OpenOffice does tend to feel like it's quite amateurish and half-baked. I felt the same way initially when I switched from Windows.

Before one goes ballistic on me let me just say I use OO extensively and am an avid GNU/Linux fan in fact, this is typed on a Mepis PC.

At least Dana was willing to try Free/Libre software and was brave enough to voice his opinion.

The fact is, MS Access is still a lot better than what is offered in the Free/Libre Software world. It fills a niche, something like between those who uses a spreadsheet as a database and those power users who run MySQL/PostgreSQL.

Yes I do agree that OO serves most people's needs 90% of the time, but once in a while we tend to miss some of the features that MS Office has. In fact, where is that word count feature?

On the other hand, for organisations to even consider moving wholesale to OO, it must match what MS Office has to offer.

Novell's wholesale migration to OO doesn't count coz the have the Linux gurus around to customise the stuff and after all they have to eat what they hope to sell. How many organisations can say the same?

Eric
Malaysia

Eric Yeoh (not verified) - Fri, 2005-01-21 00:38.